Flashmag! Issue 178 November 2026 Flashmag! Numéro 178 November 2026 Edition 178 Novembre 2026 | Page 22

22
Epilogue: The Verdict
What the dossier establishes. The motive: resources, markets, strategic position. The means: banks, armed forces, intelligence agencies. The opportunity: new, indebted, fragile states. We have confessions( Iran), convictions( ELF), official apologies( Belgium), parliamentary reports( Libya), and archival records( Haiti). The pattern repeats itself: we strike, we reap the benefits, we do not rebuild.
Flashmag! Issue 178 November 2026
What it does not establish. No evidence proves a single, coordinated plan to create failed states. The report on Libya describes, above all, improvisation. The strongest argument, therefore, is not that of an invisible hand directing everything. It is that of a system in which a country’ s fragility is tolerated, sometimes exploited, rarely remedied, and in which the beneficiaries have never had any interest in seeing this change.
“ Ordo ab chao”: the origin of a phrase, not yet a proven doctrine. The Latin phrase“ order out of chaos” is first and foremost the motto of the Supreme Council of the 33rd Degree of the Scottish Rite, proclaimed in Charleston on May 31, 1801, with a symbolic meaning of the passage from darkness to light. Its use as a secret agenda of the West stems from conspiracy literature, not from archival documents. What is established is the existence of a concept of“ creative destruction” among neoconservatives: in 2002, Michael Ledeen( American Enterprise Institute) wrote that creative destruction was the United States’“ middle name,” and that it was time to export the democratic revolution once again.
This is the defense’ s argument. Textbooks emphasize that external and internal explanations complement each other: Ghana and South Korea, which had comparable incomes in 1960, took sharply divergent paths.“ Internalists” stress the role of poor governance and ineffective leaders, while economic historians highlight the influence of local institutions and climate. The great powers had local accomplices, and some interventions had sincere supporters. In a detective novel, the final chapter delivers justice. Here, it remains to be written.
Hubert Marlin Elingui Jr. Journalist

22